Home | Search NHNE

 

 

 

NHNE Special Report:
Friday, January 28, 2000

NHNE Follow-Up:
Wapnick on the Hugh Lynn Version of "The Course"


"News,
Inspiration,
& Consumer Protection
for Spiritual Seekers"

------------

NHNE Follow-Up:
Wapnick on the Hugh Lynn Version of "The Course"
Friday, January 28, 2000

------------

Total NHNE Mailing List:
Last Mailing: 1925
This Mailing: 1921

------------

Subscribe NHNE, send a blank email message to:
nhnelist-on@mail-list.com

Unsubscribe NHNE, send a blank email message to:
nhnelist-off@mail-list.com

To read current NHNE posts:
http://dispatch.mail-list.com/archives/nhnelist

To keep NHNE on the radar screen of planet Earth:
http://www.nhne.com/main/donations.html

P.O. Box 2242
Sedona, AZ USA 86339

ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

Thanks to Val Scott for passing on the letter from Kenneth Wapnick concerning the Hugh Lynn version of "A Course in Miracles" (see below).

For more information on the Hugh Lynn Cayce Course controversy and other Course issues:

NHNE: SPECIAL REPORT: A Course In Controversy:
http://www.nhne.com/specialreports/srcoursehlcversion.html

INFORMATION ABOUT THE COURSE COPYRIGHT ISSUE:
http://nen.sedona.net/circleofa/copyinfo.html

CIM COPYRIGHT WEBSITE:
http://www.whitmorelaw.com/CIM_Copyright.html

TALK.RELIGION.COURSE-MIRACLE:
http://www.deja.com/group/talk.religion.course-miracle

FOUNDATION FOR A COURSE IN MIRACLES:
http://www.facim.org/

THE FOUNDATION FOR INNER PEACE:
http://www.acim.org/

ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

THE EARLY MANUSCRIPT OF "A COURSE IN MIRACLES" GIVEN TO HUGH LYNN CAYCE
Kenneth Wapnick, Ph.D.

In light of the misinformation circulating about the early manuscript of "A Course in Miracles" -- referred to as the "Hugh Lynn Version" -- I believe clarification is required. Let me begin by presenting the facts that relate to the history of that early manuscript. I am here summarizing what I have already detailed in my book "Absence from Felicity: The Story of Helen Schucman and Her Scribing of A Course in Miracles," (http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ISBN=0933291086/newheavenneweartA/) and in more succinct fashion in the preface to the pamphlet "Errata for the Second Edition of A Course in Miracles."

Helen took down her internal dictation in stenographic notebooks, using her own version of shorthand, and dictated these notes to Bill. Helen intentionally omitted some material while dictating to Bill, who typed Helen's dictation. We later termed this the "Urtext," a word usually used to denote the original manuscript of a later published literary work. At that time, Helen and Bill were in occasional contact with Hugh Lynn Cayce, son of the renowned psychic Edgar Cayce, and President of the Association for Research and Enlightenment in Virginia Beach. Helen valued his opinion and he was most interested in her work. For that reason, Helen shared the material with him to secure his advice and comments.

In 1972, Helen and Bill gave to Hugh Lynn a copy of what was then the completed manuscript. This is what has been called the "Hugh Lynn Version." It was made clear to Hugh Lynn that Helen and Bill were providing these pages for his personal review and comments, and that the manuscript was *not* to be shared with others except for his son, Charles Thomas. Hugh Lynn died in 1983, but Charles Thomas Cayce, current President of the A.R.E., recalls conversations in which this point -- so central to Helen's feelings of privacy -- was understood by all parties involved.

After seeing some of the early and later chapters of the text, Hugh Lynn commented to Helen and Bill that he thought that perhaps more than one source was involved, presumably since the writing styles were so discrepant, especially when one compared the early scribing -- what now roughly constitutes the first four chapters of the text -- with what came later.

Hugh Lynn's observation goes to the heart of the matter of the editing, and how and why it proceeded. Again, "Absence from Felicity" goes into this in more detail, so that interested readers may wish to consult it if they so choose. There are two relevant issues here, and they bear on what Helen and Bill (and later I) came to refer to as Helen's "scribal uncertainty" or "pedagogical caution" in introducing a thought system that was so alien to the world's thinking:

1) The early months of the dictation -- again, we are speaking of what are now roughly the first four chapters of the text -- were experienced by Helen as a dialogue or conversation between her and her inner Voice, which she identified as Jesus, in which the actual Course material itself was only *a portion* of the dictation. Personal material -- meant only for Helen and Bill -- was part of what she had written down, and it was her very specific guidance that this was not to be included in the published version. This personal material also included many references to psychologists and various psychological issues and subjects, which were also not meant for the public, but rather were to help Helen and Bill make the bridge between *their* psychological understanding and that of the Course.

2) In addition to the interspersal of the personal material and discussion of various psychological issues with the Course teaching, there is the issue of Helen's *scribal uncertainty* and *pedagogical caution*. These interferences certainly affected her writing during this period. I provided one such example in "Absence from Felicity," where the story of the so-called "celestial speed-up" message is recounted. This "explanation," which Helen never said came specifically from Jesus, but rather was "given" her, speaks of people losing more than they were gaining, necessitating a "celestial speed-up" in which certain people were being called back -- including Helen and Bill -- to lend their talents on behalf of the "plan." Helen later insisted upon removing this inconsistent material.

Therefore, what was taken out of the original material was *meant to be taken out* by Helen, as instructed by her Voice, since it detracted from the actual teaching message of "A Course in Miracles," and could have seemed to contradict that message, thus confusing its students. Helen and Bill had removed most of this material by the time I saw the early manuscript. However, Helen felt that additional material needed to be removed for the published edition. Helen made these deletions and changes and did not truly consider them to be important, as they were never meant to be part of the published Course.

Further, obvious editorial revisions were also necessary -- punctuation, paragraphing, capitalization, etc. -- all of which are documented in my book. I might also add that the editing that Helen and I completed was Helen's work. Any thought that it was I who did the editing could only be held by someone who clearly did not know Helen. As I have said many, many times, Helen was extraordinarily protective of "A Course in Miracles," and would not have allowed anything to be done with the material without her approval. Indeed, during our long period of editing, I functioned more or less as Helen's secretary, implementing the changes that she wished.

Again, anyone who knew Helen (and Bill), would appreciate the fact that "A Course in Miracles," as it is published, reflects the guidance that she followed and then implemented. Therefore, readers of the published Course (especially now that the second edition includes the earlier inadvertent typing omissions) can rest assured that they have before them in the published edition the expression of what was given to Helen by her inner Voice, the true teachings of "A Course in Miracles."

In 1990, Louis Schucman, Helen's widowed husband, assigned to me and I then copyrighted The Unpublished Writings of Helen Schucman, which, among other things, included the notebooks and Urtext, as well as all subsequent revisions up to but not including the published version. This was done to protect Helen's frequently expressed wish for privacy, to which she zealously clung and with which Louis identified. Helen, Bill, and I felt that the long process of editing -- from notebook to publication -- did full justice to a public edition of "A Course in Miracles," while at the same time respecting Helen's and Bill's wish and inner guidance that the personal and other material not be included in the public version.

Therefore, even though Helen's guidance was to eliminate both the personal material and confusing language from the final edition, the published Course clearly is intended to be read and studied by all students of "A Course in Miracles." All of us at the Foundation for A Course in Miracles and Foundation for Inner Peace earnestly hope that Helen's fervent wish for privacy will be honored and respected by all Course students. This can only be accomplished if the early manuscript of "A Course in Miracles" remains unpublished.

In summary:

1) The early manuscript provided to Hugh Lynn Cayce was the incompletely edited combination of the notebooks, Urtext, Helen's first retyping, and the first complete draft (1972).

2) This manuscript was given to Hugh Lynn Cayce by Helen for comment only, with the understanding that it would not be shown to the general public.

3) After 1972, Helen, with my assistance as well as Bill's, personally revised the manuscript to ensure that the final (published) version of "A Course in Miracles" had eliminated:

a - personal guidance and information meant only for her and Bill

b - contradictory or confusing metaphysical and psychological concepts that she had introduced, especially in the first four chapters of the text

c - various other similar material, including awkward, confusing, or inconsistent language

4) At Louis Schucman's request, I copyrighted "The Unpublished Writings of Helen Schucman" in 1990, including all Helen's notebooks and successive revisions of "A Course in Miracles," which include this early manuscript.


------------

David Sunfellow, Founder & Publisher
NewHeavenNewEarth (NHNE)
a 501(c)3 non-profit organization
P.O. Box 2242
Sedona, AZ USA 86339

Primary eMail: nhne@nhne.com
Secondary eMail: nhne@wildapache.net
NHNE: http://www.nhne.com/
Phone: (928) 282-6120
Fax: (815) 346-1492

Subscribe NHNE Mailing List:
send a blank message to <nhnelist-on@mail-list.com>

Review Current NHNE Mailing List Posts:
http://dispatch.mail-list.com/archives/nhnelist

Subscribe NHNE News List:
send a blank message to <nhnenews-subscribe@onelist.com>

Review Current NHNE News List Posts:
http://www.nhne.com/newslist/index.html

Appreciate what we are doing?
You can say so with a tax-deductible donation:
http://www.nhne.com/main/donations.html


 

 

 

Special Reports Archive

 

 

 


Home | Top | Search NHNE